Process chain · HSV corrections · epistemic walls

Scientific methods

Publication shows method discipline, not automatic truth. Hash identity supports custody; it does not upgrade claims. Cross-validation completeness is audited from physical returns only.

Status: METHODS_BOARD_C1
Evidence class: EPISTEMIC_PROTOCOL · Claim ceiling C1 · no promotion
BODYTWIN_VALIDATED=NO · LIVE_FIREWALL=NO · TAGMATA=SOURCE_GAP

Chain

Process

Source bind→Rehash→Negative fixtures→Independent review→Adjudication→Claim ceiling hold

HASH_MATCH ≠ CLAIM_TRUTH
HASH_MATCH ≠ SCIENTIFIC_TRUTH
ENGINEERING_PASS ≠ SCIENTIFIC_VALIDATION
HTTP_200 ≠ CAPABILITY_VALIDATION
AGENT_AGREEMENT ≠ REPLICATION
DISPLAY_TEXT ≠ AUTHORITATIVE without serialization bind
WORKSPACE ≠ EXECUTED_RETURN
DOI ≠ OPEN_LICENSE
VISUAL_SALIENCE ≠ EVIDENCE_STRENGTH

Process gap

THREE_ROUND_CROSSVALIDATION

Public field: NOT_ESTABLISHED · Mistral R1/R2/R3=WORKSPACE_ONLY

Mistral R1/R2/R3 as supplied are WORKSPACE/ATTACK plans, not fully executed materialized cross-validation returns. THREE_ROUND_PROTOCOL_COMPLETED = NOT_ESTABLISHED. Missing executed returns were not synthesized.

Corrections

C1–C5 applied before publication

C1_CLT: germane = resource allocation (not unqualified additive three-load doctrine)
C2_UNCERTAINTY_VIZ: tested-condition language only
C3_HICK_HYMAN: HF relation + HCI hypothesis; not validated UI law
C4_RAG: diagnostic proxy; not hard gate / resilience proof
C5_OPEN_SOURCE: absolute OS independence withdrawn

Bibliography anchors (8): see HSV derivative · Machine /research/methods/state.json