Corrected publication · nest under existing research · C1
Sanitized derivative of the Hard/Soft/Visual research strand. AXIOM corrections applied. Cross-validation three-round protocol is not established: Mistral artifacts are workspace/attack plans, not executed returns.
Status: CORRECTED_PUBLICATION_C1
Evidence class: PROCESS_GAP_PRESERVED · Claim ceiling C1 · no promotion
BODYTWIN_VALIDATED=NO · LIVE_FIREWALL=NO · TAGMATA=SOURCE_GAP
Parent adjudication
NEXUS_OMEGA_AXIOM_FINAL_VALIDATION_HARD_SOFT_VISUAL_SYMBIOSIS_20260918_R0
PASS_WITH_MAJOR_CAVEATS_C1_SOURCE_FOUNDATION_ACCEPTED_CROSSVALIDATION_PROTOCOL_NOT_FULLY_ESTABLISHED
Cross-validation
Mistral R1/R2/R3 as supplied are WORKSPACE/ATTACK plans, not fully executed materialized cross-validation returns. THREE_ROUND_PROTOCOL_COMPLETED = NOT_ESTABLISHED. Missing executed returns were not synthesized.
| File | Bytes | SHA256 (bound) | Class |
|---|---|---|---|
NEXUS_GROK_MISTRA-VIBE.txt | 102440 | 6d0ceb5ab35f6880… | GROK_COMPOSITE_C1 |
mistral-r1-cross-validation-workspace.md | 9548 | e652b98198bc055f… | MISTRAL_WORKSPACE_ONLY |
mistral-r2-second-cross-validation-attack-workspace.md | 20239 | 004c9f56172e8eb7… | MISTRAL_WORKSPACE_ONLY |
mistral-r3-final-adversarial-cross-validation-workspace.md | 21141 | d5c8e79fb71db650… | MISTRAL_WORKSPACE_ONLY |
NEXUS_OMEGA_AXIOM_TO_GROK_MISTRAL_HARD_SOFT_VISUAL_SYMBIOSIS_ARCHITECTURAL_RESEARCH_ORDER_20260918_R0.txt | 28102 | 9a2bf584607f2e1a… | ORDER_TEXT_C1 |
AXIOM corrections C1–C5
C1_CLT · SUPPORTED_WITH_CAVEATSCognitive Load Theory informs NEXUS resource-allocation design (intrinsic / extraneous / germane as analytical lenses). Germane load is treated as allocation toward schema construction under limited working memory — not an unqualified additive three-load doctrine that automatically validates UI choices.
MUST_NOT: unqualified_additive_three_load_doctrine · CLT_as_validated_UI_law · working_memory_reduction_as_automatic_validation
C2_UNCERTAINTY_VIZ · SUPPORTED_WITH_CAVEATSUncertainty visualization guidance is bound to tested conditions in cited HCI literature (e.g. frequency framing, HOPs, VSUP under studied tasks). Universal slogans such as ERROR_BARS_ALWAYS_BAD are not authorized.
MUST_NOT: ERROR_BARS_ALWAYS_BAD · universal_viz_ban_without_condition
C3_HICK_HYMAN · RESEARCH_CANDIDATEHick–Hyman describes a supported human-factors relation between choice entropy and reaction time under studied conditions. NEXUS treats application to forum/UI surfaces as an HCI hypothesis — not a validated UI law and not a hard gate.
MUST_NOT: hick_hyman_as_validated_ui_law · hick_as_hard_gate
C4_RAG · RESEARCH_CANDIDATEHollnagel RAG (respond / monitor / learn / anticipate) is a tailored diagnostic proxy for resilience-engineering questions. It is not a NEXUS hard gate and does not prove system resilience.
MUST_NOT: rag_as_hard_gate · rag_as_resilience_proof
C5_OPEN_SOURCE · NOT_VALIDATEDNEXUS publication uses a provider-neutral foundation with mixed access and license statuses. ABSOLUTE_OPENSOURCE_INDEPENDENCE is withdrawn. Absolute open-source independence is not established.
MUST_NOT: ABSOLUTE_OPENSOURCE_INDEPENDENCE
Integration
HARD/SOFT/VISUAL are functions per node under existing Architect/Symbiosis contracts. No separate HARD/SOFT/VISUAL microservices.
| Layer | Functions |
|---|---|
HARD | carry_decision_tokens · constrain_claim_ceiling · gate_intent_before_praxis · preserve_hash_bindable_state |
SOFT | explain_hard_for_humans · surface_uncertainty_and_gaps · must_not_override_hard |
VISUAL | present_evidence_class_labels · support_intent_surfaces_only · must_not_imply_truth_from_salience |
Architect profile HARD_SOFT_VISUAL_PROFILE: MAY discover_hsv_contracts, compare_node_hsv_coverage, detect_collapse_or_duplication, propose_extend_existing_contracts; MUST_NOT change_policy, promote_claims, self_authorize_high_impact, create_parallel_hsv_services.
Evidence classes: CANONICALRESEARCH_CANDIDATEENGINEERING_PASSSCIENTIFICALLY_VALIDATEDLIVE_VALIDATEDSUPPORTED_WITH_CAVEATSCONTESTEDUNKNOWNSOURCE_GAPPROCESS_GAPNOT_VALIDATED
Source anchors
| ID | ACCESS | LICENSE | TYPE | CLAIM_SUPPORTED | LIMITATIONS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
PADILLA_UNCERTAINTY_VIZ | DOI_RESOLVABLE_PAYWALL_OR_PUBLISHER_TERMS_MAY_APPLY | NOT_ASSUMED_OPEN; DOI_NE_OPEN_LICENSE | PEER_REVIEWED_PRIMARY_OR_SURVEY | Uncertainty-viz errors under limited working memory (condition-bound) | Task/population specific; not universal ERROR_BARS ban |
KALE_HOPS | DOI_OR_PUBLISHER_PAGE | NOT_ASSUMED_OPEN; DOI_NE_OPEN_LICENSE | PEER_REVIEWED_HCI | Animated outcome ensembles can aid uncertainty communication in studied settings | Not a NEXUS validation; animation ≠ evidence strength |
CORRELL_VSUP | DOI_OR_PUBLISHER_PAGE | NOT_ASSUMED_OPEN; DOI_NE_OPEN_LICENSE | PEER_REVIEWED_VIS | Palette designs that suppress value under high uncertainty (studied) | Palette heuristic ≠ scientific claim upgrade |
SWELLER_2019 | DOI_OR_PUBLISHER_PAGE | NOT_ASSUMED_OPEN; DOI_NE_OPEN_LICENSE | EDUCATIONAL_PSYCHOLOGY_THEORY | Working-memory limits; germane as allocation toward schema construction | Not unqualified additive three-load UI doctrine |
CHANDLER_SWELLER | DOI_OR_PUBLISHER_PAGE | NOT_ASSUMED_OPEN; DOI_NE_OPEN_LICENSE | EDUCATIONAL_PSYCHOLOGY_EMPIRICAL | Extraneous load reduction under instructional conditions | Instructional materials ≠ NEXUS production UI proof |
HICK_1952 | DOI_OR_HISTORICAL_ARCHIVE | NOT_ASSUMED_OPEN; DOI_NE_OPEN_LICENSE | CLASSIC_HF_EMPIRICAL | Choice information vs RT relation (studied) | Not validated NEXUS UI law |
HYMAN_1953 | DOI_OR_HISTORICAL_ARCHIVE | NOT_ASSUMED_OPEN; DOI_NE_OPEN_LICENSE | CLASSIC_HF_EMPIRICAL | Stimulus information vs RT (studied) | Not validated NEXUS UI law |
CHUANG_RAG_DIAGNOSTIC | DOI_OR_PUBLISHER_PAGE_WHERE_APPLICABLE | NOT_ASSUMED_OPEN; DOI_NE_OPEN_LICENSE | RESILIENCE_ENGINEERING_FRAMEWORK | Four potentials as formative diagnostic questions | Not hard gate; not resilience proof for NEXUS |